Back in July, Jason Chung, a fellow at The Project on Law and Mind Sciences at Harvard University Law School, got keyboards tapping everywhere with a post at The Situationist entitled, Negative Press: Is ESPN Killing the National Hockey League by Influencing Public Attitudes?As a long-time fan of the NHL, it was an interesting read to say the least, and one that had my head nodding in agreement more often than not. From where I sit, there's little doubt in my mind that the relentless barrage of negative press the league endured throughout the playoffs and beyond was triggered in part by the programming decisions made in Bristol, Conn.
Now Chung is back, and his timing once again in fortuitous, as his latest post looks at ESPN's stake in promoting the success of Major League Soccer: Manufactured Hype: Can ESPN's Agenda-Setting Behaviour save Major League Soccer?
It's an interesting questions to ask, especially as a number of fans of the sport are beginning to question whether or not the sort of hype ESPN is delivering is actually hurting the league rather than helping it.
As my FanHouse colleague David Warner pointed out yesterday, D.C. United's own Bobby Boswell, former MLS defender of the year, has something of a bone to pick with ESPN, essentially accusing it of promoting Beckham at the expense of the sport itself.
Then again, there are other times when you have to wonder just what side ESPN is really on.
What's worse, as concern about the severity of Beckham's ankle injury linger, others are wondering out loud whether or not the hype is starting to backfire on Beckham and the league -- something which has to be considered particularly unfair given reports on just how badly hurt the England international really is.But in the end, all of that is really short-term static. As much respect as I have for Chung, I don't think MLS needs saving. In fact, I think that despite the short-term apathy of some American sports fans that translates into anemic television ratings, that MLS has a bright future.
Why do I say that? Anybody with half a brain understands that America is undergoing a profound demographic shift in its population. A couple of years back in New York, Spanish-language radio broadcasts of the New York Mets were already getting better ratings than the Devils and the Islanders.
A couple of weeks ago in the press box at RFK before a D.C. United match, a couple of reporters were joking about ESPN's new MLS slogan: "You're a Soccer fan, you just don't know it yet." In the moments that followed, a number of my friends started throwing out alternatives -- including, "MLS: We've got the demographics."
It's no lie. Going forward, America is going to have more and more of a Latin flavor. And as those Latins integrate into society and start flexing their economic muscle, they're going to be buying tickets to matches. In a way, it's already happening, as huge crowds usually turn out for matches pitting MLS squads against their Mexican League counterparts.
Back in March, I saw better than 26,000 fans fill RFK Stadium for a match between United and CD Chivas on a weeknight that was cold and rainy. Had the weather been better, I wouldn't have bet against a walk-up crowd of 35,000 or more.
So while MLS won't be turning down Mr. Beckham's help, we ought to acknowledge that he's here, in part, to surf the demographic tidal wave. I suspect that's the case with ESPN too.














Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
8-14-2007 @ 11:41PM
George B Vieto said...
David Beckham won't be the savior of the MLS. Latinos will root for their kind of player. The hype of David's appearence makes PacMan Jones wrestling debut look like PacMan was the second coming the late Big Cat Ernie Ladd by comparison. Remember bait and switch tactics will backfire on the company that practices false sport hero worship.
Reply
8-15-2007 @ 1:31AM
JJ said...
Beyond Hispanics, there are few people that are true die-hard MLS fans. Most soccer people would much rather watch the Premier League, while I belive Hispanics prefer to watch their native teams instead of the MLS. I just dont see the MLS catching on when there is the NFL, NBA, MLB and NHL. While Beckham has provided a momnetary spotlight on the league, the longer he is out with injuries, the more casual fans will tire of waiting. I know I'm sick of seeing his commercials.
Reply
8-15-2007 @ 12:10PM
Samantha said...
JJ is completely wrong with his first statement. Hispanics are very much the "fairweather" fans of the league. they showed up in Chicago a couple weeks ago for Blanco's first home league game with the Chicago Fire. They'll show up when the MLS team closest to them is playing Chivas USA. Not because they like Chivas USA, but because they like Chivas from the Mexican league.
Step into the supporters section of any team, outside of Chivas USA, and you'll be hard pressed to find that many of the hardcore fans are Hispanics which is unfortunate. You're correct in that they rather watch the Mexican league and that there are a lot of soccer snobs who won't watch MLS because it's not the EPL. There's the problem, MLS can't convince the existing soccer fans that they have a product worth watching and they're having a hard time breeding new fans.
I'm sure you could care less about the hardcore fans of MLS but I just wanted to correct you with a fact.
Reply
8-15-2007 @ 12:37PM
Greg Wyshynski said...
"MLS can't convince the existing soccer fans that they have a product worth watching and they're having a hard time breeding new fans."
One of the biggest issues with the league is that there's no glory in its franchises. Sure, DC United is the most successful side in league history, but fans in other cities don't treat them like a baseball fan would treat a visit from the Yankees or Red Sox.
MLS has always been star-oriented, which works for a sport like the NBA but not (save for rare cases) in team sports like football, soccer and hockey. Emotional attachments to franchises -- both opposing and your own -- are the key to the success of any team sport league.
Reply
8-15-2007 @ 6:28PM
Steve said...
Hahahahahaha.
Reply
8-15-2007 @ 6:35PM
Steve said...
Not sure why it didn't show up, by my haha was to the claim that "In fact, I think that despite the short-term apathy of some American sports fans that translates into anemic television ratings, that MLS has a bright future."
Reply
8-15-2007 @ 10:33PM
Ebscer said...
JJ nails it on the head... Soccer fans in general realize that the Premiership (in England) and teams in other leagues are better than the MLS... beckham helps because it's step away from being a minor league, but it needs quality players across the board for that to happen...
Reply
8-15-2007 @ 10:49PM
Stuart said...
Samantha, since we are "correcting with facts" here, At EVERY Dynamo game in Houston you will find at least 100 Hispanic members of "El Batalon" who are certainly "hard core" fans. The hispanic population here has witnessed the local MLS team play their best FMF teams toe to toe and come out successful. As far as laughing at the brightness of the future of MLS Steve, How about 7.5 million dollars for just 4 years of name logos on their jerseys?
Reply
8-16-2007 @ 5:20PM
pete said...
Oh great, more eroding of American culture, what next, bullfighting on ESPN?
Reply
8-18-2007 @ 10:42PM
Jonathan said...
MLS has a product that is worth watching. The L.A. Galaxy beat Pauchua in Superliga which is ranked 23rd in the World. The Houston Dynamo beat them once and would like have beat them recently if it weren't for a red card after 15 minute which meant that had play the majority of the match down one player. MLS will continue to grow with hispanic and with non-hispanic fans. I lived in Europe for eleven years (Italy, UK, Spain) and watched some great soccer. I listened to those who put down MLS then actually started attending games and found these pundits were dead wrong about MLS. It's a great league with an already established hard core of fans - these will continue to slowly grow.
Beckham will bring in those who haven't checked out MLS. The majority of these people will stay.
Reply